Post Standard columnist Sean Kirst recently had an interesting post on his blog discussing the primary elections for Onondaga County Executive.
Titled County Executive . . .Hungry For Change?, Sean highlighted a comment posted on his forum that claimed that voters casting ballots in the primary had voted for change, going outside the usual power brokers and sending a message to the politicians.
Cooler heads then prevailed in the comments, pointing out that both of the candidates unendorsed by their party officials, Ed Ryan for the Democrats and Joanie Mahoney for the Republicans, are not exactly “outsiders.” Ryan has been in the County legislature for 30 years and Mahoney’s family has a long history of campaigns and election wins between Joanie and her dad Bernie.
The post then opens up a discussion thread I’d like to take up: what would it take to get a real outsider to run and what would that campaign look like?
What does “real outsider” mean? A non-politician? Someone with no real name recognition? A regular Joe or Jane whose tolerance for the status quo erupts and forces them to enter the ring? Party affiliated or no party affiliation?
I have a cardinal rule of politics: “pay your dues.” I don’t appreciate candidates with no past experience at any level of government running for high levels of public office, especially legislative offices. Successful work as a part of a body of officials requires an understanding of negotiation, compromise and collegiality. Mavericks find it hard to get anything done if they’re leading a charge with no one behind them.
Executive level jobs are slightly different, because a major part of the job is management of government workers and departments. This is a skill set that people can acquire from non-governmental experiences: academia, churches, labor unions, private enterprise, military etc. Unfortunately, executives are frequently people with management skills but with no vision for change and no ability to adapt their executive decisions to changing public opinion or new information (for example, Nick Pirro’s refusal to consider changes to the County’s ossified plans for the siting of raw sewage treatment plants, despite being presented with ideas for better technology that was safer and cleaner.)
So my “outsider” would have to be someone that had some experience with the process, at the very least someone who attends public meetings, has expressed themselves in print or verbally on issues facing our community, someone who has obviously spent some time thinking about the process and its problems. In addition, the candidate needs to have some positive name recognition in the community just to get their campaign past the gatekeepers of public discourse, largely a press that can be hostile to non-establishment candidates.
My “outsider” would also have to run solely as an independent. Any identification with a party ties you to the ward heelers and their personal intrigues and dust-ups, regardless of a candidate’s best intentions. Foregoing party affiliations puts major roadblocks in the way of a candidacy–financial, party identification by voters, volunteer support. However, a truly independent and maverick outsider may be able to turn all those negatives into positives.
The three major requirements for a true outsider candidate:
1) One or two important and exciting ideas/goals.
2) Explain the ideas/goals so everyone can understand them.
3) The ideas/goals are THE topic all candidates discuss in the campaign.
The stickiest issue in this discussion is money. Money often comes with strings that limits the independence of even the best candidates. Candidates without resources will be unable to counter a barrage of negative ads by their well-financed opponents or counter attempts by the press to marginalize their campaign by harping on their relatively cash-poor operation. Does a true outsider candidate have to be a wealthy person financing their own campaigns, like Mike Bloomberg or Tom Golisano? Can a true outsider candidate garner numerous small contributions by regular folks, perhaps by using the internet, like Howard Dean or Barack Obama? It probably has to be one or the other.
To quote Pink Floyd: “Is there anybody out there?”